WWI YEARS - FLANDERS
According to collective family memory on Arthur's reminiscences about the war, he made mention of "Ypres", "The Somme", "Flanders Field" and "Passiondale". He was trained as a "Lewis" Machine Gunner. He once endured a three day bombardment of shelling, huddled up with others in a right-angled pocket/corner of a trench. His remembering of this would each time lead to him alluding to the fact that he had a bad toothache for the whole duration of the shelling. He and the others were later shocked after the shelling had stopped, and a whistle was blown for some sort of a roll-call. The shock was to realise that only their own small pocket of soldiers, plus a few others, had actually survived the bombardment. Apparently most of that group of 100+ men died in the bombardment, whence Arthur's descendants are lucky to be here.
![]()
Arthur left Australia with reinforcements for the 2nd Battalion. With the 1st, 3rd and 4th Battalions this formed the 1st Brigade of the 1st Division, AIF.
Previously the battalion had taken part in the ANZAC landing on 25 April 1915 at Gallipoli. After the withdrawal from Gallipoli, the battalion at first returned to Egypt and then in March 1916 sailed for France and the Western Front. The battalion is particularly mentioned in connection with the battles of Pozières, Bullecourt, Ypres 1917 and Menin Road.
As the war progressed, the overseas divisions were organised into I ANZAC Corps (1st and 2nd Australian Divisions, and the New Zealand Division) and II ANZAC Corps (4th and 5th Australian Divisions). Beginning in March the troops were moved to France, and by July and August were heavily involved on the Western Front. The 5th Division was the first to engage the Germans on 5 July 1916 in a small but bloody engagement at Fromelles in northern France. Shortly after, the 1st, 2nd and 4th Divisions became embroiled in the first Somme offensive, at Pozières and Moquet Farm.
The 2nd battalion took part in operations against the Germans at the Somme in France and around Ypres in Belgium. It's first major action in France was at Pozières in the Somme valley in July 1916. It later fought at Ypres in Flanders, then returned to the Somme.
In the following year, 1917, the Australians were again heavily engaged, in March at Bapaume, in May and June at Bullecourt and Messines, and from September to November in the great battles of the Ypres offensive - Menin Road, Polygon Wood, Broodseinde, Poelcapelle and Passchendaele. In early 1917 the German Army withdrew to the formidable defences of the Hindenburg Line. As the 2nd Battalion advanced towards these defences in April 1917, Private T. J. Kenny attacked several enemy machine gun positions with grenades, earning the Victoria Cross.
After Bullecourt, the battalion returned north and spent much of the rest of 1917 fighting in increasingly horrendous conditions around Ypres. Arthur was hospitalised on 2 November 1917 and then shipped back to England.
Flanders
From mid 1916 onwards, France and Flanders became the AIF's main theatre of war.
Flanders is a geographical region in the north of Belgium, corresponding to the Flemish people, and is a constituent part of the federal Belgian state (although the precise geographical area of "Flanders" has changed a great deal over the centuries). The official language is Dutch.
Flanders (and Belgium as a whole) saw some of the greatest losses of life of the First World War, including battles around Ypres and the Somme.
Ypres was the centre of intense and sustained battles between the German and British Commonwealth forces.
Ypres, 1919
![]()
Ypres rebuilt - Town Hall or Coth Hall.
Australian troops march through the same scene, Ypres - 25 October 1917
"Ypres has been a very fine city but there is not much left of it now, they have very wide streets and also a beautiful Cathedral. It is at this Cathedral that the Kaiser said he would be crowned King of Belgium, but I am afraid it will not be there when the war is over." (16/8/16 - Diary of Kenneth Sydney Day; later badly wounded on 3/5/17 at battle of Bullecourt and returned to Australia).
Ypres is a historic place. It was at the centre of an area with a population of hundreds of thousands by the 1400s, and was a great cloth marketing town. The Cloth Hall or Lakenhalle was built in the thirteenth century and demonstrated the wealth and power held by the merchants of the town. During World War I Ypres was all but totally destroyed. In 1934 King Albert I and Queen Elisabeth opened the reconstructed belfry and the remainder of the hall slowly followed over the next 24 years. It has been rebuilt and designated a City of Peace, with similar status as Hiroshima in this regard. The Cloth Hall houses a First World war museum named "In Flanders Fields".
Ypres was a key position because it stood in the path of Germany's planned sweep across the rest of Belgium and into France from the North. The German army formed a salient around the city, fortifying positions along the surrounding hills. British, French and allied forces made costly advances from the town of Ypres against the Germans on these surrounding hills.
In the First Battle of Ypres (1914) the British captured the town from the Germans. In the Second Battle of Ypres (1915) the Germans used poison gas for the first time on the Western Front. Chemical weapons had been used elsewhere as early as October 1914 when shrapnel shells containing an irritant substance were fired by German artillery at Neuve Chapelle. In January 1915, shells containing xylyl bromide (tear gas) were fired against Russian troops at Bolimow in Polond on the Eastern Front. The use of chemical weapons escalated massively when, on 22nd April 1915, 168 tons (171 tonnes) of chlorine gas were released from 4,000 cylinders on a 4-mile (6.5km) front against French and Canadian divisions in the Ypres Salient. The Germans also began using phosgene gas in December and 120 men were killed. In the beginning the gas was released from canisters and carried by the wind over the opposing front lines. Later, artillery shells were filled with gas and detonated in the opposing trench system.
Mustard gas, also called Yperite from the name of this city, was used for the first time in the autumn of 1917. Mustard gas was used to deluge the town of Ypres on the night of 12th/13th July 1917, causing 2,014 casualties. The gas shells burst on impact to release the liquid contents which evaporated to give a virtually-odourless gas. Inhalation of the gas was rarely fatal, but caused severe pains in the head, throat and eyes, vomiting and bronchial irritation. Many victims would suffer from recurrent chronic bronchitis for years afterwards. Over the following weeks more than a million gas shells were fired, killing 500 British soldiers and injuring thousands more.
Of the battles, the largest, best-known, and most costly in human suffering was the Third Battle of Ypres (21 July to 6 November, 1917, also known as the Battle of Passchendaele) in which the British, Canadians and ANZAC forces recaptured the Passchendaele ridge east of the city at a terrible cost of lives. After months of fighting, this battle resulted in nearly half a million casualties to all sides (including 36,500 Australians), and only several miles of ground won by Allied forces.
The Third Battle of Ypres was scheduled to start on 25th July but due to several factors, it was delayed until 31st July. It started at 3:50 am on 31st July but days before that a preliminary bombardment for the offensive was commenced, to which the Germans replied by shelling the roads and communication trenches. Mustard Gas is recorded to have been used over the next few days. The mustard gas attacked sensitive parts of the body, caused blistering, damage to the lungs and inflammation of the eyes, bringing about blindness in bad cases (sometimes temporary in lesser cases) and great pain.
Australian infantry with gas masks, Ypres 1917 - Photo by Captain Frank Hurley.
French soldiers wearing gas masks on the Western Front (posed picture).
A gas bomb lands and explodes
![]()
Troops blinded by gas.
Gas attack photographed from a plane.
As the above photo shows, all degrees of gas exposure could be encountered, from severe near the point of gas canister impact explosion to less severe from anywhere under the spread of a gas sheet diffusing downwind. It is thought that Arthur may not have got a highly direct dose of gas, yet was seriously enough affected to suffer lasting damage to his lungs, which probably brought about low resistance to later lung infections. He may have suffered recurrent periods of bad health even after return to England.
Even faint or secondary contact with remnants of the gas could have seriously deletarious effect. Nurses were affected just from the traces of gas absorbed on the clothing of gassed soldiers: "... The mustard gas cases started to come in. It was terrible to see them. I was in the post-operative tent so I didn't come in contact with them, but the nurses in the reception tent had a bad time. The poor boys were helpless and the nurses had to take off their uniforms, all soaked with gas, and do the best for the boys. Next day all the nurses had chest trouble and streaming eyes from the gassing. They were all yellow and dazed. Even their hair had turned yellow and they were nearly as bad as the men, just from the fumes from their clothing" (Account from a nurse at No.11 Casualty Clearing Station near Godewaersvelde).
As for the indirect effect of the gas on nurses: "Dear Mr. Fairchild, It is with regret that I have to inform you of the death of your daughter, Miss Helen Fairchild, RN, on January 18, 1918, while on duty with Base Hospital No.10, American Expeditionary Forces, France. D.E. Thompson, Superintendent Army Nurse Corps" (The cause of Nurse Fairchild's death was "acute atrophy of the liver," according to General John J. Pershing. Exploratory surgery revealed a massive stomach ulcer, caused or made worse by exposure to Mustard gas and other gasses used by the enemy).
Also concering the experience of nurses at Base Hospital No. 10 in the Passchendaele area, Third Battle of Ypres, Paul B. Hoeber later wrote: "The first hard experience came when an exceedingly large convoy of patients, overwhelmed by Mustard gas, and the picture of intense suffering, poured in on them in great numbers... 600 in less than 48 hours, and it was repeated for many a night".
Most recovered from gas effects but there were still deaths, and these increased from 1916 through 1917. There were 230 gas casualties suffered by the AIF in 1916, of which 18 were fatal. The bombarding of the Noreuil Valley with over 5,000 gas shells in April 1917 caused only 5 casualties. The 5th Division suffered 150 gas casualties at Bullecourt in May 1917 and the 3rd Division took 425 gas casualties in the Battle of Messines.
The above figures are from before the introduction of Mustard Gas.
Largely as a result of Mustard Gas, Australian gas casualties suddenly soared to 1,675 in October 1917 and to 1,086 in November 1917 when Arthur was incapacitated.
The first use of Mustard Gas against Australian troops was against the Siege Brigade on 10 July 1917. To spread Mustard Gas effectively, the Germans devised a new shell which combined Mustard Gas with High Explosive. Not only did this spread the gas more efficiently, it got rid of the telltale "plop" sound of a gas shell. Mustard shells sounded just like high explosive. Mustard Gas was also a blistering agent that even in low concentrations could blister the skin, blind the eyes and damage the lungs. It reacted strongly with water, so that sweat could draw it out of the air and onto the skin. It could also remain on the ground (or on the clothing of affected soldiers which nurses handled), poisonous and dangerous for up to 72 hours.
Factors contributing to the large toll included men stumbling into gas filled shell holes in the dark; failure or inability to remove contaminated clothing; failure to put respirators on quickly enough; and, most importantly, removing them too early.
Modern map of Ypres area. The ridge running south-west to north-east from Kemmel in the south to Passendale (Passchendaele) in the north is indicated on the map in light brown at the contour line of 50 metres above sea level.
The shaded area represents the ground won by the Germans as a result of the first great gas attack at the opening of the Second Ypres battle.
Old German bunkers still standing near Ypres.
Battle of Passchendaele. Australians on a duckboard track in Chateau Wood near Hooge, Ypres area,
29 October 1917. Photo by Frank Hurley.
Where was the 1st Division (and the 2nd Battalion)?
The writer does not know how the Australian army operated but in former times the Australian tradition was to copy English proceedures. The English practice was that each unit kept a daily record of their activities, referred to as "war diaries".
In March 1916 the Division moved to France, taking over part of the line in the around Armentieres.
On 23 July 1916, it joined the Somme Offensive, capturing the town of Pozieres at great cost. A second tour of Pozieres followed in August and a third at Flers in October after a rest break in the Ypres sector.
In 1917 it was involved in the pursuit of the Germans to the Hindenburg Line. While maintaining outposts close to that line around Lagnicourt, the division was struck by a powerful German counterattack on 15 April 1917 and beat it off. In May it relieved the Second Division in the Second Battle of Bullecourt.
After a rest spell, the division returned to the Ypres Salient and participated in the Third Battle of Ypres, in which it had its greatest successes at Menin Road in September and Broodeseinde in October.
The writer has found some fragmentary references to the history of the 2nd Battalion. It fought at the battles of Bullecourt (1917 May 3-17) and Messines 1917 (1917 July 6-1917 Nov.). At Messines Ridge the Allies also tunnelled underground and set 21 huge mines totalling 450 tonnes of the high explosive Ammonal. At zero hour at 03:10 on 7 June 1917, after the most intense bombardment of the entire war, nineteen of the allied mines were detonated, killing an estimated ten thousand German troops in moments. The explosion was said to be audible as far away as Dublin, and was likely the loudest man-made noise made up to that date. (The British lost the location data of the two mines which failed to detonate, and a high voltage powerline pylon was built over one which exploded during a thunderstorm in 1955. The 21st mine has been located nearby but no attempt made to explode or remove it.)
A total of 117,500 AIF troops were at the Western Front. Australians fought at various places along the front line. The names of some major battles are:
Bullecourt
11 April to 16 June 1917. Includes the actions at First Attack on Bullecourt on 11 April and Lagnicourt on 15 April. as well as the Battle of Bullecourt 3 to 17 May 1917. Units involved included the 1st, 2nd, 4th and 5th Divisions.Flanders Offensive
7 June 1917 to 10 November 1917. Battles included:
Messines: 7 to 14 June 1917. The 3rd and 4th Divisions participated.
Nieuport: 10 to 11 July 1917. The 2nd Tunnelling Company participated.
Ypres 1917: 31 July 1917 to 10 November 1917. Also known as the Third battle of Ypres. This battle is further subdivided into:
Menin Road: 20 to 25 September 1917 (1st and 2nd Divisions); Polygon Wood 26 September to 3 October 1917 (4th and 5th Divisions); Broodeseinde (1st, 2nd and 3rd Divisions) 4 October 1917; Poelcappelle (2nd and 3rd Divisions) 9 October 1917; 1st Passchendaele (3rd Division) 12 October 1917 and 2nd Passchendaele 26 October 1917 to 10 November 1917 .(Source: The "AIF Project", a research activity at the Australian Defence Force Academy, Canberra
http://web.archive.org/web/20040228113618/www.unsw.adfa.edu.au/~rmallett/about3.html
NB: Above battles listing omits to state the Division/s involved at 2nd Passchendaele. Also, another reference begins the Menin Road fighting instead on 16 September 1917.)
On 16 September 1917, in a battle near Menin Road out from Ypres, 11 divisions were sent against the Germans along a 13 km segment of the front line. The 1st & 2nd Divisions AIF had 1.8 km of this width of attack. The Australians advanced to the north edge of Glencorse Wood to Hannebeek Swamp and bogs in the Nonne Boschen copse and then onto Albert Redoubt, Verbeck Farm and Polygon Wood and into Wilhemline. By 20 September the advance had stalemated apparently, around Polygon Wood. Results of the action included 2,754 casualties in 1st Division. (The British lost 20,000 to 25,000 men and the Germans a similar number.). The 2nd Division lost similar numbers. The 1st & 2nd Division were then relieved and the 5th Division was set to hold or advance the Flanders line. Fighting continued and the 5th Division suffered 5,471 dead & wounded.
The 1st & 2nd Divisions were then placed back on the front line at Broodseinde Ridge. There they joined other ANZACS and there were 4 ANZAC Divisions side by side at the centre of a line of 13 divisions along a 13 kilometre front. On their left on the northern boundary was Gravenstafel Spur. Broodseinde was roughly in the middle of the Australian segment of the front, on the right was the village of Molenaareishok. The British had abandoned Broodsende Ridge after the 2nd Battle of Ypres in 1915 and after that the Germans had made it their headquarters. Thus by October 1917 the Australians were facing the district German headquarters. On 4 October both sides attacked each other in steady drizzle rain, commencing at daylight ( 5.20 a.m.) The Germans opened up with heavy shelling and trench mortars. The men of the 1st & 2nd Divisions laying in shell holes suffered 1 in 7 men hit by this bombardment. By 6 a.m. the Allied artillery was returning the barrage. Three Australian Divisions lost 6,500 men killed & wounded which was 20% of their strength. The rain increased from a drizzle and started to pour down but General Haig demanded an advance. By 9 October the Australian 2nd Division reached Keilburg Spur en route to Passchendale but were were driven back. By 12 October 1917 the 11 ANZAC Corps, with the 3rd Australian & N.Z. Division and the 4th Division AIF in support, had some units reach the outskirts of Passchendaele but many of the troops and their equipment got stuck in the mud. The 5th Division was in the line for 8 weeks and suffered 38,093 casualties. British and Canadian Corps took Passchendaele on 6 November 1917 (or some accounts state that the village of Passchendaele was taken by Canadian troops on 30 October).
British Prime Minister David Lloyd George was opposed to the Passchendaele offensive, and later came out highly critical of General Haig’s strategy and tactics in his published memoirs, but in the absence of a credible alternative to Haig he felt obliged to sanction Haig’s plans at the time. Little advance had resulted from the Battle of Poelcappelle and the First Battle of Passchendaele, on 9 October and 12 October respectively. The Allies were themselves nearing exhaustion as German reserves released from the Eastern Front were poured into the ridge. To aid in their defence the Germans made full use of mustard gas (as opposed to chlorine gas used in The Second Battle of Ypres). The Second Battle of Ypres had begun on 22 April 1915, when gas was used for the first time at Steenstrate six kilometres to the north of the town.
Unwilling to concede failure, Haig pressed on with a further three assaults on the ridge in late October. The eventual capture of Passchendaele village by British and Canadian forces on 6 November finally gave Haig an excuse to call off the largely stalemated offensive, claiming success. By consulting death lists it is seen that 2nd Battalion was present at the capture of Passchendaele. James Royal Lambert, age 23, of 2nd Battalion was killed at Passchendaele on 6 November 1917.
Following this, the AIF was withdrawn from the Ypres salient.
The Third Battle of Ypres was, like its predecessors, a very costly exercise. The British Expeditionary Force (BEF) incurred some 310,000 casualties. There was a similar, but lower, number of German casualties, estimated as 260,000. The gain to the "victors" after all this was a mere few kilometres.
Haig came under intense criticism both in 1917, and since, for persisting with the Third Ypres offensive after it became clear that full breakthrough was unlikely. However, rainfall also greatly added to the woes of the troops as it was by far the heaviest known for many years. Fighting had taken place around Ypres since 1914 without the kind of problems experienced during Third Ypres. Haig himself argued that when regarded as a battle of attrition, the German forces could less afford the loss of men than the Allies, who by this time were being supplemented by the entry into the war of the U.S. Needless to say, controversy will continue, but most historians have questioned Haig’s decision not to call off the offensive earlier than November. The struggle and slaughter continued until November 1917 when finally the almost exhausted Allies pushed to the top of the ridge at Passchendale. They left behind them over a quarter of a million casualties; 90,000 of which had melted away into the mud never to be found again. Lieutenant Angel of the 2/4th London Btn, Royal Fusiliers, recorded that the bodies in the mud were continually disturbed by shell impacts and the whole place became "a mess of filth and slime and bones and decomposing bits of flesh...". But after all this, and the winning of Passchendale ridge, the ground was held only until the following April when the Germans counter attacked, sweeping across the land bought by the British only months before for a price that was all too high. The result was one of the costliest and most futile campaigns in military history, with the few miles of mud captured all lost again in the spring of 1918.
All told, this Third Ypres (Passchendale) campaign cost Australia 39,093 casualties and Mullet (1999) has described the campaign as "a muddy salient leading nowhere". The bottom line was that the step by step tactics relied on artillery, which in turn relied on a transportation infrastructure. This infrastructure was slowly whittled away, and it collapsed entirely when the weather went so bad. The casualties in the Australian artillery became so great that it was almost no longer effective by November 1917. The infantry found the valleys impassible, the wire uncut, and the barrage too thin to protect them. Casualty evacuation was of course no less difficult than resupply, and the ratio of killed to wounded increased from 1:4.2 to 1:2.7 before the Australians were replaced by the Canadians who went to take Passchendaele.
Sutton Veny army base, England
(Or view everything here as a single webpage - which is not recommended, unless you have a fast modem, as the images may take too long to load.)
REFERENCES
Macdonald, L., 1978. The called it Passchendaele. Penguin Books, 1978
Mullet, R., 1999. The interplay between technology, tactics and organisation in the First AIF.
MA (Hons) Thesis, Australian Defence Force Academy.
Taylor, F.W. & Cusack, T.A., 1942. Nulli Secundus: A History of the Second Battalion, A.I.F. 1914-1919.
Burridge, Perth, 1992 Facsimile reprint. [Not seen]
Prior, R. and Wilson, T., 1996. Passchendaele - The Untold Story. Yale University Press.